There are two kinds of Thanksgiving hosts: the ones who make every pie from scratch, and the ones who know when to call in reinforcements. Manhattan has local dessert makers worth checking before you automatically add a supermarket pie to the cart—and a couple of excellent country-road stops are worth considering, too.
Start with a dedicated pie shop
TheraPie is a Manhattan bakery to check when pie is the main event. Ask which flavors are available for Thanksgiving, whether whole pies require advance ordering and when pickup takes place. Find its current information at www.therapiellc.com ↗.
Explore smaller-batch baking
Little Batch Co. is another local business to investigate for holiday treats and desserts. Small bakeries may offer limited quantities or special preorder windows rather than everyday inventory. Confirm its latest menu and ordering instructions directly at www.littlebatchco.com ↗.
For cakes and special-order desserts: Bourbon & Baker
Bourbon & Baker at 312 Poyntz Avenue offers a bakery alongside its restaurant. Its published bakery menu includes cakes, cheesecakes, tortes and cupcakes—useful choices when not everyone at Thanksgiving wants pie. The bakery has advertised special orders, but current Thanksgiving selections, prices, deadlines and pickup arrangements still need confirmation. Call 785-320-4959 or visit bourbonandbakermanhattan.com ↗.
Consider a custom dessert
If your gathering calls for decorated sweets or a different kind of centerpiece, check Sweet Pieces by Natalie for current offerings, lead times and availability: www.sweetpiecesbynatalie.com ↗.
Worth the drive: The Fork in the Road near Riley
At 11363 Kansas Spur near Riley, The Fork in the Road is an honor-system farm market known for homemade foods including pies, carrot cake and other seasonal treats. The selection changes, so don't assume a particular pie will be waiting for you. The market lists hours of 6 a.m.–10 p.m. and accepts cash, check, Venmo and PayPal, but not credit cards. For Thanksgiving availability and larger orders, call 785-443-1796 before making the drive. www.theforkintheroadks.com/about ↗
A Wamego favorite: Friendship House
Friendship House at 507 Ash Street in Wamego makes its bakery items from scratch. Its published restaurant menu features fresh-baked pie Friday through Sunday, and its own materials invite advance orders for holiday baked goods, including pies and rolls. Ask which whole pies are offered for Thanksgiving and whether a special pickup schedule applies; the ordinary menu isn't a confirmed 2026 holiday order form. Call 785-456-9616 or visit friendshiphouse.biz ↗.
Five questions to ask before placing an order
What Thanksgiving flavors are actually available this year? What is the last day to order? What sizes are offered, and how many people will each serve? When and where is pickup? Are there allergy or ingredient details available for guests who need them?
How much dessert do you need?
A nine-inch pie is often cut into six to eight generous slices, though serving sizes vary. For a large gathering, offer two or three flavors rather than guessing that everyone wants pumpkin. A fruit pie, a classic custard or pecan option, and a non-pie dessert can cover a range of preferences.
Order early, then confirm
Thanksgiving bakery menus and cutoff dates change every year. This guide highlights businesses to contact, not confirmed 2026 preorder offers. For The Fork in the Road and Friendship House, plan ahead for the drive and verify whole-pie availability before leaving Manhattan. Before paying, verify the menu, price, pickup time and cancellation policy with the bakery itself.
A good Thanksgiving dessert doesn't have to come from your oven. Sometimes the smartest holiday tradition is supporting someone in Manhattan who is much better at pastry than you are.




